|
What Is A Gift?
“A gift is a voluntary transfer of property for which
the donor receives no benefit in return. For there to
be a gift, the following conditions must be met:
 |
The donor transfers ownership of property (cash,
or gifts in kind such as goods or land) to a registered
charity:
|
 |
The transfer is voluntary; and
|
 |
No benefit is provided to the donor, or a person
selected by the donor, unless the benefit is of nominal
value.”
CCRA
document RC4142 (E) Rev.02 |
In assessing whether a donor has obtained a benefit from
the making of a donation, the jurisprudence establishes that
the receipt of a tax benefit as a consequence of the donation
does not, in and of itself, affect the status of the donation
as a gift. In the Queen v. Friedberg, 92 DTC 6031, the Federal
Court of Appeal stated:
"Thus, a gift is a voluntary transfer of property owned
by a donor, in return for which no benefit or consideration
flows to the donor (see Heald, J. in the Queen v. Zandstra...)
The tax advantage received from making charitable gifts is
not normally considered a "benefit" within this
definition, for to do so would render the charitable donation
deduction unavailable to many donors."
The Federal Court of Appeal has held that an individual can
purchase and immediately gift an item even if their motive
is to gain a tax advantage. The court stated:
“It is clear that it is possible to make a “profitable gift”.
Where the actual cost of acquiring the gift is low, and the
Fair Market Value is high, it is possible that the tax benefits
of the gift will be greater than the cost of acquisition.
A substantial incentive for giving property is thus created
through these benefits.”
(The Queen vs. Friedberg)
|